How to Choose a Mechanical Seal for a Pump

Single or double seal? Five deciding factors, five real-world causes of failure—and when packing is the better choice.

How to Choose a Mechanical Seal for a Pump

Mechanical seal failure is the most common cause of pump downtime. A new seal “the same as the old one” will fail in the same way—if no one has addressed why the first one failed. Here’s how to choose the right seal.

How a mechanical seal works

Two lapped faces: one rotates with the shaft, the other remains stationary. A thin film of the fluid between them lubricates and cools the faces. That’s why dry running destroys a seal—without the film, the faces are ruined in seconds.

Single or double?

A single seal is sufficient for water, oils and non-aggressive fluids where minimal leakage is acceptable.

A double seal (with a barrier fluid) is used when:

The barrier fluid lubricates and cools the seal, and creates a barrier against leakage. The higher cost pays off in service life and safety.

Five parameters that matter

  1. Fluid – composition, concentration, solid particles and lubricity. These determine the materials used for the faces and elastomers.
  2. Temperature – operating and peak temperatures. These determine the elastomers and cooling requirements.
  3. Pressure in the seal chamber – this differs from the discharge pressure and depends on the pump design.
  4. Speed and shaft diameter – peripheral speed determines the face materials and seal balance.
  5. Condition of the machine – runout, alignment, vibration and bearings. The best seal can’t save a pump in poor condition.

Five common causes of failure

  1. Dry running – closed suction, air in the pump or cavitation. The faces are ruined in seconds.
  2. Wrong elastomer – O-rings swell or harden in a fluid that “no one mentioned.”
  3. Machine condition – vibration and misalignment; the seal is the first to bear the brunt.
  4. Fluid crystallizing on the faces – salt and sugar solutions crystallize after the pump stops.
  5. Incorrect installation – wrong working length, damaged faces or contamination.

Does the seal keep failing? Don’t buy a third one just like it. Our pump repairs start with diagnosing the cause, not replacing the part.

When packing is a better choice

For older machines, abrasive fluids and low-speed applications where controlled leakage is acceptable. Read more: Packing: types, selection and installation.

Seal selection isn’t a catalogue item

The POWERseal range covers both single and double seals. More important than the catalogue is diagnosis: we analyze the application, recommend a solution, install it—and stand behind the result.

Get advice on seal selection →

Are you ready to put your seal selection worries behind you? Contact us

and get valuable advice and information on industrial seals

Logo Pokorny Industries

Pokorny Industries Partnership in quality

All prices excluding VAT

© Pokorny industries s.r.o. 2026 - all rights reserved

Made by servisdesign